Showing posts with label Bill O'Reilly. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bill O'Reilly. Show all posts

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Grading PolitiFact: O'Reilly v. Obama on health care reform approval (Updated x3)

The issue:



The fact checkers:

Angie Drobnic Holan:  writer, researcher
Martha Hamilton:  editor


Analysis:

The relevant exchange between Fox personality Bill O'Reilly and President Obama:
O'REILLY: But the entitlements that you championed do redistribute wealth in the sense that they provide insurance coverage for 40 million people that don't have it.

OBAMA: What is absolutely true is I think in this country, there's no reason why, if you get sick you should go bankrupt. The notion that that's a radical principle, I don't think the majority of people would agree with you.

O'REILLY: Then why do the majority people in the polls not support Obamacare?

OBAMA: Actually, I think it's pretty evenly divided.

O'REILLY: It's close.

OBAMA: It's evenly divided, Bill.
Politics Daily (yellow highlights indicate portions quoted in PolitiFact story)
On with the fact check:
Here, we wanted to referee the dispute on the poll numbers: Do a majority of people in the polls oppose the health care law? Since O'Reilly brought it up, we decided to check his statement.
Hold it right there.

PolitiFact has flubbed the fact check already.

O'Reilly:
(W)hy do the majority of people in the polls not support Obamacare?
(implicit assertion:  A majority of people in the polls do not support Obamacare)

PolitiFact version:
Do a majority of people in the polls oppose the health care law?
(implicit assertion:  O'Reilly claims a majority of people in the polls oppose Obamacare)

Granted, President Obama appeared to frame the argument the same way PolitiFact framed it.  But there's a big difference in bounding the group of persons who do not support Obamacare as opposed to the group of persons who oppose it.  A person who couldn't care less about Obamacare does not count as one who opposes Obamacare.  But that same person counts as a person who does not support Obamacare.

This is yet another PolitiFact blunder that is difficult to understand without invoking the blinders of bias as an explanation.  Isn't it basic logic?
The best evidence for O'Reilly's position was the most recent poll from the Kaiser Family Foundation and Harvard School Of Public Health. In its most recent tracking poll, it found that 50 percent of respondents had an unfavorable view of the law, while 41 percent viewed it favorably. But another 9 percent said they didn't know or didn't want to answer. Certainly, the largest category in this poll didn't like health care, but if you combined supporters with the unknowns, you do get an even split.
(blue highlights added)
On what planet does it make sense to group the unknowns with the bill's supporters?  If the unknowns belong in either group they belong with those who do not support the reform bill.  The phrasing O'Reilly used gives him a much better claim on that group.
Things get even trickier when you ask people about repealing the law, because a significant portion of those who say they view the law unfavorably also say they they are opposed to a complete repeal. The most recent Kaiser poll showed that 19 percent said keep the law as it is; 28 percent said expand the law; 23 percent said repeal the law and replace it with a Republican alternative; 20 percent said repeal it and don't replace it. That means 49 percent want the law kept or expanded, and 43 percent want it replaced with a Republican alternative or simply repealed.
(bold emphasis added)
They're not kidding when they say things get trickier.  Things get so tricky that the 19 percent who want to keep the law as it is when added to the 28 percent who want the law expanded gives us a total of 49 percent who want the law.

On this planet 28+19 typically equals 47.  Nothing like a little creative rounding to inspire confidence in a fact check.

Do the math correctly and you get approximately 47 percent in favor of the law in comparison to about 53 percent who do not favor it.  Advantage:  O'Reilly.

Update 3:

PolitiFact:
Some polls have also found that at least a portion of people who dislike the health care bill dislike it because they wanted to see more dramatic changes to the health care system. A CNN poll in December found that 13 percent of those who opposed the law did so because it wasn't liberal enough. Another 43 percent favored the bill and 37 percent said it was too liberal.
While the 13 percent figure is interesting, it doesn't affect the premise of O'Reilly's question.  It does provide material that might have informed the president's answer to the question if he had elected to use it.  But the numbers break down to 54 to 57 percent not supporting the law compared to 43 percent expressing support.  A more current CNN poll also supported O'Reilly (50-55 percent not supporting compared to 45 percent supporting).

PolitiFact's conclusion:
O'Reilly said that a "majority of the people in the polls" do not support the health care law. If we were rating Obama's statement on its own, that the public is evenly divided, we would rate that True. But O'Reilly isn't entirely wrong, in the sense that support for the bill does not hit 50 percent or higher. Taking a broad picture of the polls reveals a divided public, so we rate his statement Half True.
Obama is correct that the country is evenly divided between those who favor the reform law and those who oppose it.  But Obama's response to O'Reilly did not address the issue, which was the number of persons who did not support the new law.  Obama's response was misleading in context with O'Reilly's on a point of fact ("It's evenly divided, Bill").  Obama was wrong on that point.  O'Reilly's premise was correct.

For PolitiFact, it's the fact-checking equivalent of striking out during batting practice.  O'Reilly's premise was accurate and could have warranted anything from "Half True" all the way to "True."  Based on the flawed reasoning and botched math discussed above, PolitiFact gave him the lowball rating.


The grades:

Angie Drobnic Holan:  F
Martha Hamilton:  F


Update:

Feb 11, 2011:  It's time to belatedly recognize PolitiFact's weak admission of the point on which I criticized the story:  "O'Reilly isn't entirely wrong, in the sense that support for the bill does not hit 50 percent or higher."  Of course, it ought to have read "O'Reilly is correct in the sense that support for the bill does not hit 50 percent or higher."  And because that's the sense of O'Reilly's literal words, PolitiFact needs some sort of reason for saying that O'Reilly was wrong.  I don't think PolitiFact can make that case.  The argument might be made that he didn't provide sufficient context, but that approach ought to also apply to Obama--yet PolitiFact was willing to give Obama an unqualified "True" despite the fact that the president did not admit the sense in which O'Reilly was correct.  The grades for Drobnic and Hamilton remain the same.


Update 2:

Very early on Feb. 13, I sent a message to the writer and editor pointing out the likelihood that the 49 percent figure was wrong and the lack of support for charging O'Reilly with error.  At about 11:30 a.m. today I received a message from the editor thanking me for pointing out the error in math and pointing me to a corrected version of the story.  Corrected for the math error, that is.  O'Reilly's still supposedly wrong, for reasons PolitiFact has yet to make clear.

Here's the relevant portion of my message to Drobnic and Hamilton:

Click for larger view

Update 3 (Oct. 30, 2011): 

PolitiFact eventually corrected the 49 percent figure, replacing it with the appropriate 47 percent figure.  PolitiFact did include a correction notice this time.  The logic error in evaluating O'Reilly's statement remains the central thread of the story, unfortunately.



Feb. 12, 2011:  I misidentified the PolitiFact editor throughout the original post and the update.  The post now reflects the fact that Martha Hamilton edited the story, not Bill Adair.  My apologies for the error.  Also deleted a redundant occurrence of "adding" in the paragraph about trickiness.


Saturday, June 06, 2009

Grading PolitiFact: O'Reilly and "Tiller the baby killer"

Political bias may take a number of different forms in journalism. In the most obvious cases, a journalist employs language inconsistent with the principles of journalistic objectivity. A more pernicious form occurs via the choice of content.

I freely admit that my analysis of PolitiFact tends toward the latter type of bias. Sure, I'll defend candidate-for-president Barack Obama if PolitiFact grades him "False" simply for employing hyperbole. But ordinarily I will take the most interest in PolitiFact when it fumbles the truth on the issues I hold dear.

There it is, right there on the table. I have a political bias.

Chances are you'll never see any type of admission like that from PolitiFact. The mainstream press has a vested interest in hiding its political bias in favor of presenting itself as the dispassionate voice of truth and impartiality. And that, indeed, is how PolitiFact markets itself.

Under the surface, however, it is likely that PolitiFact writers read lefty blogs along with sites like the unabashedly liberal Media Matters for America. The analysis on this O'Reilly piece serves as an evidence of this category of journalistic bias.

Fact-checking the fact checkers


The issue:




The fact checkers:

Angie Drobnic Holan: writer, researcher
Bill Adair: editor


Analysis:

First things first: What makes this story newsworthy for a political fact-check site? Even one which has declared for itself an expanded purpose?

PolitiFact admits to using reader feedback to guide it to topics of interest. That serves as great news if you're a liberal who regularly follows the work of an organization like Media Matters for America. Or News Hounds. Both published on this O'Reilly issue before PolitiFact. Both of these partisan sources claim that O'Reilly denied that he called Tiller "Tiller the Baby Killer" except where he reported that pro-life groups had given Tiller the name.

It makes sense to start with O'Reilly's column on Tiller's murder--the one referred to in the PolitiFact headline:
It took just minutes after the report of Tiller's murder for the far-left loons to hit the websites. Postings on the Daily Kos and The Huffington Post immediately blamed me and Fox News for inciting Tiller's killer. Even though I reported on the doctor honestly, the loons asserted that my analysis of him was "hateful."

Chief of among the complaints was the doctor's nickname, "Tiller the baby killer." Some pro-lifers branded him with that, and I reported it. So did hundreds of other news sources. But the bigger picture here is the glorification of Tiller.
Take note, for we may revisit O'Reilly's words.

Drobnic's opening:
Liberals are criticizing conservative talk show host Bill O'Reilly for his harsh comments about Dr. George Tiller, who was shot to death while attending church on May 31, 2009, in Wichita, Kan.

Their argument is that O'Reilly repeatedly named Tiller as a late-term abortion provider and called him a "baby killer." That publicity contributed to Tiller's death, they say. Anti-abortion activist Scott Roeder, 51, has been charged with Tiller's murder.

Note that the first paragraph accepts the harshness of O'Reilly's words as a premise, or at least lends itself to that interpretation. I suspect Drobnic and Adair might accept this as a mistake, in retrospect. Probably Drobnic intended to present O'Reilly's supposedly harsh rhetoric as simply an allegation from liberals to whom she refers.

To her credit, Drobnic steers clear of whether O'Reilly contributed to Tiller's death. Unfortunately, without that angle this issue probably holds even less interest. What fact are we checking other than O'Reilly's supposed report about himself?

Drobnic picks up on her chosen issue:
O'Reilly responded to his critics in an opinion article posted on BillOReilly.com and in the conservative journal Human Events. He began by saying that Tiller "did not deserve his fate" and was "an American citizen entitled to protection."
And we skip ahead just a bit to reach the key passages:

O'Reilly said that liberal groups were targeting him unfairly.

"Even though I reported on the doctor honestly, the loons asserted that my analysis of him was 'hateful,'" O'Reilly wrote. "Chief of among the complaints was the doctor's nickname, 'Tiller the baby killer.' Some pro-lifers branded him with that, and I reported it. So did hundreds of other news sources."

O'Reilly went on to criticize media outlets for glorifying Tiller in order to silence those who oppose abortion, especially late term abortion.

Drobnic says that O'Reilly said that liberal groups were targeting him unfairly. But note that her evidence from O'Reilly's op-ed is talking about whether or not O'Reilly was "harsh" (supposedly "hateful," by O'Reilly's telling). The last two sentences constitute the key point at issue for PolitiFact, and it should be noted right away that the two statements appear absolutely true from the evidence Drobnic presents. Pro-lifers branded Tiller as a "baby killer" and O'Reilly did report it.

One might pause to wonder: How does PolitiFact take a literally true statement and rate it "False," as happens in this case? Typically literal truth will result in some in-between rating, such as "Barely True," "Half True" or "Mostly True." Or should, if PolitiFact was remotely consistent.

The key, of course, comes from the interpretation of O'Reilly's words. Media Matters took the statement as a denial from O'Reilly that he had attached "baby killer" to Tiller except when he reported that name as used by others.

Just one problem: It is not so easy to take O'Reilly's words that way. Not without at least considering the statement as the type of "artful" rhetoric that seems to get President Obama off the hook as often as not.

And then we have the context.

In addition to pointing out that media outlets all over the country reported that pro-life groups had called Tiller "baby killer," O'Reilly emphasized that his reporting was truthful.

Could that not have encompassed the fact that Tiller performed late-term abortions on fetuses that are fairly called by the term "baby"?

Back to Drobnic:
We wanted to see what O'Reilly had said about Tiller, to see if O'Reilly was indeed being criticized for his reporting on other groups' characterization of Tiller as he said.
Is that what O'Reilly said? Or is it simply a questionable inference made public by left-leaning bloggers? From the available evidence is it not manifestly the latter?

Drobnic goes on to document various statements from O'Reilly where he used the term "baby killer" in proximity to Tiller's name without attributing it to others. But it bears repeating that O'Reilly did not claim anything to the contrary. Rather, a charitable interpretation has O'Reilly downplaying his repeating of the supposedly harsh rhetoric by pointing out that it appeared abundantly in print, while also implicitly insisting that he would be accurate and truthful in calling Tiller a "baby killer."

Certainly it is possible to read O'Reilly less charitably. But evidence should be required for the acceptance of a less charitable reading, and Drobnic fails to deliver.

Given her dubious premise, the conclusion follows:
These instances and others we reviewed clearly show that O'Reilly was not reporting the views of others, but was expressing his own views on the doctor. O'Reilly said in his column that "Some pro-lifers branded" Tiller a baby killer, "and I reported it," as if he were reporting the views of others. But the transcripts show O'Reilly repeatedly referred to Tiller as a baby killer without attribution. So we find his statement that liberal groups are targeting him for his reporting of what others said to be False.
1) Drobnic errs in failing to offer O'Reilly the most favorable interpretation of his statement.

2) After the first failing, Drobic errs again in failing to note that O'Reilly's statement is literally true even if his supposed underlying argument fails to hold water.

It should have been impossible to grade O'Reilly worse than "Barely True," but somehow it happened anyway.

I did not bother looking for evidence that Drobnic indulged in literary borrowing from Media Matters or News Hounds. I trust she is too professional for that. However, I count it very likely that PolitiFact followed liberal blogs on this story. In the past Media Matters has even been listed as a source at PolitiFact. I think Media Matters probably remains a source, but no longer merits mention since that reflects ill on PolitiFact's objectivity. As if there was such a thing.


The grades:

Angie Drobnic Holan: F
Bill Adair: F


Afterword:

I did a little bit of Google research and, sure enough, PolitiFact often used Media Matters as a source in 2008. The practice appears to have stopped prior to the start of the new year.

Striking Media Matters from the list of sources would serve as a sign of improvement if Media Matters was no longer used as a source.

I have my doubts as to the latter.

Friday, October 24, 2008

O'Reilly nails a CNN flub

Interviewer Drew Griffin blew it, and Bill O'Reilly nailed CNN on the mistake. Good work, O'Reilly. This is why Keith Olbermann wishes he was you.



Saturday, September 29, 2007

The O'Reilly race kerfluffle





Ye Olde Tempeste in Teapot. CNN's coverage is horrible. Even the gloriously partisan Media Matters did a fairer job on the story than CNN. Compare:
During the September 19 edition of his nationally syndicated radio program, discussing his recent trip to have dinner with Rev. Al Sharpton at Sylvia's, a famous restaurant in Harlem, Bill O'Reilly reported that he "had a great time, and all the people up there are tremendously respectful," adding: "I couldn't get over the fact that there was no difference between Sylvia's restaurant and any other restaurant in New York City. I mean, it was exactly the same, even though it's run by blacks, primarily black patronship." Later, during a discussion with National Public Radio senior correspondent and Fox News contributor Juan Williams about the effect of rap on culture, O'Reilly asserted: "There wasn't one person in Sylvia's who was screaming, 'M-Fer, I want more iced tea.' You know, I mean, everybody was -- it was like going into an Italian restaurant in an all-white suburb in the sense of people were sitting there, and they were ordering and having fun. And there wasn't any kind of craziness at all."
(Media Matters)

I have yet to see a full transcript of the radio show, but the Media Matters account should cue the fair-minded person that O'Reilly's comments were not a big deal at all. CNN, in the two clips shown, consistently treated them as if they were indeed a big deal.

The key point is that CNN took comments made "later, during a discussion with ... Juan Williams" and put then onscreen while playing the audio of the earlier comments. That's a textbook case of misrepresenting the context.

Media Matters is probably tickled pink that CNN was able to distort the story beyond a mere insinuated attack.

O'Reilly, I'll give you and Juan Williams the last word.




OK, one more thing. Brian Maloney at The Radio Equalizer did a bang-up job analyzing this story, making all the points I've made and more. I'd have gone on to something else if I'd known about the job Maloney did from the start.


*****

Friday, August 03, 2007

Dennis Miller blasts Senator Dodd

Michelle Malkin has offered sufficient commentary on this one; I'm just posting so I'll have an excuse to link to the hilarious comments of Dennis Miller.

First the set-up.

O'Reilly is off on the way Democrat leaders attending the Kos convention implicitly endorses the rather base type of political dialog that regularly takes place there. O'Reilly used an distasteful image from the Daily Kos as an example, and put Dodd on the spot over it.
The image O'Reilly used is in the video. If for some reason you need a better look, go here.


Link: sevenload.com


Next thing you know, Dodd is using his bravery to make his tin cup louder as he asks for campaign contributions.
clipped from www.chrisdodd.com

blog it


Dodd's position is especially funny next to that of John Edwards. Edwards famously campaigned against Ann Coulter's lowering of political discourse (using it as one of his points of leverage to draw campaign contributions).