Context matters -- We examine the claim in the full context, the comments made before and after it, the question that prompted it, and the point the person was trying to make.
--Principles of PolitiFact and the Truth-O-Meter
Horse feathers.
The issue:
| (clipped from PolitiFact.com) |
The fact checkers:
Sabrina Eaton: writer, researcher
Robert Higgs: editor
Analysis:
As one might anticipate from the epigraph, the context serves as the key to this fact check.
Most (or at least many) people know of "Joe the Plumber," Joe Wurzelbacher, a Toledo man vaulted to modest fame after an unscripted and candid conversation in 2008 with a campaigning Barack Obama.
Since that initial boost to notoriety, Wurzelbacher entered into a congressional race as the Republican candidate in a redrawn Ohio district against veteran of Congress Marcy Kaptur. Kaptur squeezed out fellow Democrat and congressional veteran Dennis Kucinich in the Democratic primary.
The fact check concerns Wurzelbacher's status as a plumber, the Kaptur campaign's attempts to exploit that status as a campaign issue and Wurzelbacher's response to Kaptur's tactics. PolitiFact fact checks the latter, and the former two constitute the critical context.
We'll examine all three issues.
Is Wurzelbacher a plumber?