Showing posts with label Kaleem Omar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kaleem Omar. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

Journalist Kaleem Omar

In a recent post I was taken aback by the tone of a Pakistani journalist, Kaleem Omar.

According to Answers.com/Wikipedia, Omar is a poet turned journalist. Apparently his emotional approach to writing hasn't entirely eroded with the change in jobs.

Omar has an interesting approach to journalism. In the story I talked about earlier, he referred to comments by "one American Red Indian skeptic," leading me to think he may have tracked down comments by resume-enhancing former University of Colorado professor Ward Churchill.

No such luck. Omar seems to have culled the quotation from the commentary section of the liberal Web site Common Dreams, in response to a story borrowed from Agence France Presse:

ontheres July 16th, 2007 5:18 pm

“equitably distributing Iraq’s oil proceeds” to whom???
Let’s cut through the bull, our government is saying, “If you don’t turn over your oil, we’re going to bomb you to smithereens.
How I love the fostering of American democracy. Out on this reservation, where I live, there’s a saying: “White man talk with forked tongue.” No bigger fork than the one in Bush/Cheney tongues. Impeach! Impeach! Impeach!

(Common Dreams)

Way to dig into the story, there, Omar!

How does Omar know the poster is really an American Indian?
What makes this anonymous source worth quoting, other than it may suit Omar's agenda?

I have no problem with dropping the pretense of objectivity in journalism, but responsible journalism--whatever the underlying bias--at least attempts to make a reasonable case for its editorial position.

Kaleem Omar offers us a scatterbrained polemic, not responsible journalism.

I thought I was reading the LA Times

I checked on my Pakistani news source The News (International) to see if anything new was happening with the crackdown on Islamic extremists, and I ran across this rather opinionated column, which I presume is an op-ed (though it's well to remember that the American paradigm of supposedly objective journalism doesn't hold sway for most of the globe).
Iraqis protest draft oil law that
will allow US to pillage the country’s wealth
By By Kaleem Omar

Hundreds of Iraqi oil industry workers gathered in Basra on Monday to protest a draft oil law that would allow foreigners to pillage the country’s wealth. For ‘foreigners’ read large US oil companies, also known as Big Oil, with whom senior Bush administration officials have long had close ties.

The officials include President George W. Bush (who began his career in the oil business in Texas) Vice-President Dick Cheney (former CEO of Houston-based oil services giant Halliburton) and others. Chevron, a leading member of Big Oil, has even named one of its oil supertankers after Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.
(The News)
And he's just getting started! In the space of the first two paragraphs, we find him capitalizing big oil, and referring somewhat carelessly to the Chevron deal.

Yes, a supertanker was named after Condoleezza Rice, but it was renamed in 2001 after she was confirmed as Secretary of State. Prior to that, Dr. Rice served on the board of directors for Chevron, where her expertise in Soviet/Russian relations was a boon to that company.

Chevron frequently names its tankers after board members.

The funniest part of the column is when the author starts quoting anonymous U.S. skeptics regarding their opinions of the proposed oil law.

The long and short of it is that the column serves up a bizarre mix of sources and makes no attempt to apply solid reasoning to the issue.

It's written like propaganda, and I think that's no coincidence.