Showing posts with label Nathan Deal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nathan Deal. Show all posts

Saturday, August 21, 2010

Grading PolitiFact (Georgia): Nathan Deal and birther dabbling

Apologies to those who check regularly for "Grading PolitiFact" updates.  I have a PolitiFact-related research project in the works, and it's labor intensive.  PolitiFact Georgia snagged my attention, however.


The issue:




The fact checkers


Willoughby Mariano:  writer, researcher
Jim Denery:  editor
Jim Tharpe:  editor


Analysis:

The headline and the deck both place quotation marks around "dabbled."  Apparently the quotation marks are used to show that a Huffington Post reporter ("liberal bloggers") used the term in making the claim as he prefaced a question to White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs.

The term ends up the key to the entire story.

 Willoughby Mariano:
Dabble generally means to take part in something casually or superficially -- to not take it seriously. We will focus on claims that he did that with birther conspiracies.

Mariano's explanation of "dabble" suffers from ambiguity. A person who dabbles in black magic, for example, may practice the art casually in the sense of spending little time in the pursuit. But we understand the person to be practicing black magic with the expectation that it and its effects are real. By analogy, "dabbling" in birther theories means spending some casual time believing they are serious theories. In that sense they are taken seriously.  Dabbling in birther conspiracies ought to mean taking the conspiracy itself seriously, but not seriously enough to spend a serious amount of time or effort on it.

What is the evidence, PolitiFact?