Showing posts with label Robert Burns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Burns. Show all posts

Sunday, March 08, 2009

Journalists reporting badly: The Clinton "Reset" button (Udated)

The news is out for some time that the State Department and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton produced a bit of a flub during a meeting with the Russians.

The incident was amusing enough, but the mainstream media have compounded the amusement.

The St. Petersburg Times published two associated stories, one regarding the reactions to the meeting and the other about the gaffe. The first was apparently based on AP material. The second drew content from Glenn Kessler's story for The Washington Post. The story seems to underemphasize the degree of embarrassment the State Department suffered after having "worked hard" on the translation.

And while going a bit soft on the gaffe, reporters including the estimable Robert Burns described the incident incorrectly. The video clearly shows that Clinton opened the box and handed the button mock-up to Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, yet Burns' story reads thus:
Clinton handed Lavrov a green box tied with a green bow. He opened it to reveal a "reset button," a reminder of Vice President Joe Biden's recent remark that the Obama administration hopes to reset U.S. relations with Moscow.
Kessler:
Clinton began the meal by presenting Lavrov with a palm-size box wrapped in a green ribbon. Lavrov opened it up and pulled out a small plastic box with a red button that clicked — a symbol of the Obama administration's determination to "reset" the relationship.
Roll the video:



Note to the press: Get basic facts right, including incidental ones like this, and you have a better chance of getting people to trust your reporting.


Update:

Note to readers: Content providers have been more aggressive lately in getting material removed from YouTube, including the video I linked. However, the remaining still image shows Clinton with the box already opened in one hand the and the button held in the other. Lavrov did not remove the button from the box as reported in the press.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Robert Burns/AP: U.S. winning in Iraq

Despite the occasional bursts of violence, Iraq has reached the point where the insurgents, who once controlled whole cities, no longer have the clout to threaten the viability of the central government.

That does not mean the war has ended or that U.S. troops have no role in Iraq. It means the combat phase finally is ending, years past the time when President Bush optimistically declared it had. The new phase focuses on training the Iraqi army and police, restraining the flow of illicit weaponry from Iran, supporting closer links between Baghdad and local governments, pushing the integration of former insurgents into legitimate government jobs and assisting in rebuilding the economy.

(AP)

Will the reality-based community wake up and smell the coffee?

I'll fault the story for the somewhat cheap shot at Bush. Referring to Bush's speech declaring major combat operations at an end is appropriate to a degree since that speech was a chronological landmark. On the other hand, two different wars have been waged. Hussein's armies were defeated in short order. The war since that time has been waged against a different opponent. The first war featured conventional tactics. The second involved insurgency and counterinsurgency (COIN), albeit the good guys were slow to adopt the appropriate strategy when the war changed.

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Pitfalls for political progress in Iraq

Seasoned and fair reporter Robert Burns brings us a story about Iraqi politics:
COMBAT OUTPOST RADWANIYAH, Iraq - In the rural outskirts of Baghdad, where the war seems distant in Iraq's new period of relative calm, a prominent Sunni tribal chief makes no bones about what is lacking in the drive to turn security improvements into lasting economic and political change.

"Up to now we have seen nothing from the government," Sheik Ayad Abdul-Jabar al-Jabouri, wearing traditional headdress and robe, said with more than a hint of disdain for the Shiite-dominated leadership in the capital.
(read the rest at Yahoo!news)
Abdul-Jabar waxes hyperbolic, to be sure. The government has made some strides in terms of supporting infrastructure and al-Maliki's move in putting down Shiite militias cannot reasonably be overlooked. That said, the overall complaint is undoubtedly mostly true at present. The government has had its hands full just providing security and functioning. Some promising legislation has passed, but it will take additional time before the government consolidates civic control commensurate with its military control.

The best case scenario has the al-Maliki government following up its military success with consolidation of its federal power while keeping the main three geographical regions satisfied. Oil revenue will help substantially toward that end, but in the end it comes down to the will of the government. Iraq has a problem with corruption, unfortunately, so achieving the best case scenario without some hiccups should not be expected.

07-15-08 fixed headline typo

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

AP reporter Robert Burns on the surge

BAGHDAD (AP) - AP Video The new U.S. military strategy in Iraq, unveiled six months ago to little acclaim, is working.

In two weeks of observing the U.S. military on the ground and interviewing commanders, strategists and intelligence officers, it's apparent that the war has entered a new phase in its fifth year.

(Breitbart.com)

I wonder what the reality-based community has to say about this?

Other than "Grumpy Old Man" in the commentary section at "Shakesville" (formerly "Shakespeare's Sister").
And Bryan, would you please explain in detail just how the surge is working so wonderfully as I see people being blown to bits every ******* day in Baghdad.
(Haloscan, Shakesville)
Hold onto those tinfoil hats! This could be a rough ride!