Showing posts with label TARP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TARP. Show all posts

Sunday, February 07, 2010

Grading PolitiFact: President Obama and what happened before he walked in the door

Obama's Jedi mind-trick ability comes to the fore nearly to the point of "Simon says."


The issue:



The fact checkers:

Catharine Richert:  writer, researcher
Greg Joyce:  editor


Analysis:

PolitiFact usually treats truth claims one of three ways.  One, rate the literal truth of a statement.  Two, rate the underlying argument.  Three, do a little of both.  But sometimes PolitiFact takes the fourth option.

To be sure, Catharine Richert's story sets out to rate the literal truth of this Obaman utterance.  As to whether she hit that mark, read on and judge for yourself.

As usual we emphasize the context of the statement in question. Curiously, in this case Richert failed to list a source.  I write that confidently, given that all save one of the referenced sources was dated in the year 2009, before President Obama gave his first State of the Union address.  The other one was written in 2001.

In any case, here is the version of Obama's speech from whitehouse.gov:
At the beginning of the last decade, the year 2000, America had a budget surplus of over $200 billion.  (Applause.)  By the time I took office, we had a one-year deficit of over $1 trillion and projected deficits of $8 trillion over the next decade.  Most of this was the result of not paying for two wars, two tax cuts, and an expensive prescription drug program.  On top of that, the effects of the recession put a $3 trillion hole in our budget.  All this was before I walked in the door.  (Laughter and applause.)

Now -- just stating the facts.  Now, if we had taken office in ordinary times, I would have liked nothing more than to start bringing down the deficit.  But we took office amid a crisis.  And our efforts to prevent a second depression have added another $1 trillion to our national debt.
(yellow highlights added)
The president said quite a bit within the space of those two paragraphs, and it would be fair to summarize it as "to whatever degree the state of the union is a fiscal nightmare, it is the fault of Bush (or the Republicans)."  But this is another of those times where PolitiFact shows little interest in the underlying argument.

Friday, June 26, 2009

Grading PolitiFact: President Obama and TARP profits

The dilemma over grading the literal statement and the underlying argument breaks President Obama's way. Again.


Fact-checking the fact checkers


The issue:




The fact checkers:

Robert Farley: writer, researcher
Bill Adair: editor


Analysis:

The key to this piece of PolitiFact perfidy forms a paradox: If you look closely enough at an issue you can miss something. Writer Robert Farley takes casual notice of some of the evidence that something's amiss, but assures the public that the picture is legit once the focus is drawn sufficiently tight.

By analogy, picture a convenience store. The store is stocked with beer and cigarettes, primarily the former. The cigarettes sold out, but the beer isn't moving. The store owner announces a "profit" on the cigarettes, even though the store is still in the red to the tune of the cost of its beer inventory minus the cigarette profits.

This is yet another statement that is technically true as uttered but easily misleading. The Times' paraphrase adroitly illustrates this: "Obama says government has so far turned a profit on money used to stabilize banks."

There's nothing like having the mainstream media take the misleading aspect of one's technically true statement, then put it on the deck of a fact check piece and finally place a graphic next to it pronouncing it "True."

Thanks, PolitiFact!


The grades:

Robert Farley: F
Bill Adair: F

The statement was technically true but slightly misleading. PolitiFact amplified the misleading nature of the statement, making the situation worse.