Showing posts with label healthcare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label healthcare. Show all posts

Friday, March 16, 2012

Grading PolitiFact (Florida): The IPAB, rationing, and Pat Boone

PANTS ON FIRE – The statement is not accurate and makes a ridiculous claim.
--Principles of PolitiFact and the Truth-O-Meter


The issue:

(clipped from PolitiFact.com)

The fact checkers:

Angie Drobnic Holan:  writer, researcher
Aaron Sharockman: editor


Analysis:

The Independent Payment Advisory Board is a "death panel" as Sarah Palin originally used the term.

PolitiFact is dead set against admitting it.

It's fun to watch the contortions as PolitiFact does its usual denial in the context of the Pat Boone television ad.

PolitiFact:
Here’s part of Boone’s criticism; it focuses on the law’s Independent Payment Advisory Board, or IPAB:

"This IPAB board can ration care and deny certain Medicare treatments so Washington can fund more wasteful spending. Your choices could be limited and you may not be able to keep your own doctor. ... Washington politicians, like Bill Nelson, are ignoring the problem, putting their own re-elections first. Call Sen. Nelson. Urge him to support real Medicare reform and protect our seniors."

The ad makes several claims, but here, we’re going to specifically fact-check Boone’s claim that the IPAB "can ration care and deny certain Medicare treatments so Washington can fund more wasteful spending."
The statement PolitiFact chooses is obviously a compound claim, including the assertions that the IPAB can ration care, that it can deny certain Medicare treatments, and that some combination of the former two enable Washington to fund "more wasteful spending."  The obvious warrants mention because PolitiFact makes little effort to keep its treatment of the constituent statements distinct from one another.

PolitiFact:
Under the health care reform law, if Medicare spending growth is projected to exceed pre-set targets, the IPAB must come up with plans to slow that increase. If Congress does not act on the recommendations within a set time, IPAB’s recommendations automatically go into effect. (For a more detailed explanation of how this would work, we recommend this April 2011 report from the independent Kaiser Family Foundation.)
PolitiFact summarizes the function of the IPAB reasonably well.  The challenge comes from trying to identify IPAB recommendations that do not result in economic forces that result in the rationing of Medicare services, though there's always the option of ignoring the economic implications.
We should emphasize here that IPAB recommendations would not apply to any particular individual, but would be across-the-board policy recommendations applied to the entire program. Given Boone’s rhetoric, some people could get the wrong impression that the board would review individual patient treatments and deny care. That’s not the case.
There's nothing about Boone's statement that particularly suggests he's talking about a policy managed at the level of individual patients.  No statement is idiot proof, so PolitiFact's observation is effectively irrelevant without something straight from Boone that contributes to a misleading impression for a reasonable person.

PolitiFact (bold emphasis added):
Boone calls the members of the IPAB "15 unelected, unaccountable bureaucrats." Rather than career government workers, the law says IPAB members shall include people with national recognition for health care expertise, including "different  professionals, broad geographic representation, and a balance between urban and rural representatives." (Board members are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate.) On the point of accountability, we’ll just repeat that Congress retains the power to overrule any IPAB recommendations, though there are special rules in place so that the recommendations cannot be filibustered or otherwise delayed. 
Though it's a bit of a digression, it is useful to point out PolitiFact's failure to address Boone's point about a lack of accountability for the IPAB.  The IPAB is parallel to the Supreme Court in some ways.  The board members have no constituency or higher body to which they are accountable.  It is an independent board.  It says so right on the label.  It is irrelevant to the accountability of the board members that Congress has a shot to overrule its recommendations.  That is a check on its power, not a form of accountability.
The IPAB has restrictions on what it can recommend in the name of cost savings. It can’t raise rates, drop beneficiaries or ration care. Here’s the exact language from the law itself:

"The proposal shall not include any recommendation to ration health care, raise revenues or Medicare beneficiary premiums under section 1818, 1818A, or 1839, increase Medicare beneficiary cost-sharing (including deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments), or otherwise restrict benefits or modify eligibility criteria."

Boone says the IPAB seeks to reduce Medicare spending so the government can spend money on other "wasteful" things. But the IPAB is intended to slow Medicare spending if its growth exceeds pre-defined targets. It’s also capped on how much it can reduce spending: It can recommend measures to bring Medicare within specific cost-savings targets and no more.
1)  Given the second paragraph above along with the stipulation that the IPAB cannot recommend rationing, we again find ourselves confronted with the question of what IPAB can do to control costs--and whether those measures result in rationing after all.

2)  The third paragraph repeats the pattern noted above regarding Boone's point about accountability.  PolitiFact does not address the congressional option of wasting money saved through the implementation of IPAB recommendations.

3)  One continues to wonder what the IPAB can do to cut Medicare spending without encouraging rationing as a result.  The "pre-defined targets" are a soft cap on Medicare spending.  Capping spending directly encourages rationing of services.  If a family goes out to dinner with a cap on spending then it is price-rationing the meal.  If a dining-out IPAB finds a way to reduce the tab to bring the family's meal down within the bounds of a soft cap that is likewise a rationing force.  It's inevitable.  One can plan to stiff the server, but that route by analogy leads to yet more rationing in the health care context.

PolitiFact:
Our ruling

Boone said, "This IPAB board can ration care and deny certain Medicare treatments so Washington can fund more wasteful spending." Actually, the law specifically states that the board cannot ration care. The board doesn’t look at individual patients or deny individual treatments. Instead, it makes system-wide recommendations to rein in the future growth of Medicare spending, and it makes those recommendations within limited parameters. It also was created to stop runaway spending growth within the Medicare program itself, not to divert money to other budget items. We rate Boone’s statement Pants on Fire.
It's just crazy to render a ruling without giving a single example of a cost-cutting strategy the IPAB can recommend without some type of rationing occurring as a result.  If the IPAB can only recommend measures that lead to rationing then the ruling "Pants on Fire" cannot reasonably apply to Boone's claim.

Maybe the IPAB has tools at its disposal that will limit costs but PolitiFact simply failed to take note?

Let's look at the Kaiser Family Foundation summary of the IPAB to see if it helps answer that question.
The statute sets target growth rates for Medicare spending. The target is not a "hard cap" on Medicare spending growth, but if spending exceeds these targets, IPAB is required to submit recommendations to reduce Medicare spending by a specified percentage (discussed below).
There's the soft cap.  It's important to note that a soft cap is nothing like no cap at all.  The IPAB is charged to act any time Medicare spending exceeds the targeted goal.  The recommendations must reduce the amount of excess spending:
If projected growth for the implementation year exceeds the target, and the medical care component of the CPI-U exceeds the CPI-U, then IPAB is required to develop and submit a proposal to bring Medicare per capita growth within the target in the implementation year, subject to the applicable limits (maximum savings) on reductions described below.
Congress cannot overrule the Board's recommendations without substituting its own recommendations to meet the cost reduction goal:

Finally we get to see some examples of recommendations the IPAB might make (bold emphasis added):
IPAB is prohibited from including any recommendation that would: (1) ration health care; (2) raise revenues or increase Medicare beneficiary premiums or cost sharing; or (3) otherwise restrict benefits or modify eligibility criteria. In addition, for implementation years through 2019, mandatory proposals cannot include recommendations that would reduce payment rates for providers and suppliers of services scheduled to receive reductions under the ACA below the level of the automatic annual productivity adjustment called for under the Act.16 As a result, payments for inpatient and outpatient hospital services, inpatient rehabilitation and psychiatric facilities, long-term care hospitals, and hospices are exempt from IPAB-proposed reductions in payment rates until 2020; clinical laboratories are exempt until 2016. These exclusions leave Medicare Advantage, the Part D prescription drug program, skilled nursing facility, home health, dialysis, ambulance and ambulatory surgical center services, and durable medical equipment (DME) as the focus of attention.
The above implies that price controls on some services and medical supplies will end up the IPAB's method of choice for controlling costs.  It is widely recognized in economics that price controls--price ceilings--reduce supply.  Reducing the supply results in a rationed market for those services or goods.

Put simply, text of the health care law is incorrect when it says the IPAB cannot cut costs via rationing.

Journalistic curiosity ought to prompt hard questions on these points--especially in a fact check.  One could hazard a guess that journalistic curiosity was anesthetized by ideology.


The grades:

Angie Drobnic Holan:  F
Aaron Sharockman:  F

The first PolitiFact Bias research project will suggest that all "Pants on Fire" ratings are unfair and the result of a subjective determination by the responsible PolitiFact teams.  Pat Boone's statement was neither false nor ridiculously false in any non-subjective sense.  It was at least somewhat accurate when considered objectively.

These journalists are probably either biased in favor of health care reform roughly along the lines of the ACA or else painted into a corner on this ruling by other PolitiFact rulings that were influenced by ideology.  It's hard to explain the collected set of rulings on health care reform any other way.


Addendum:

After publishing, I ran across "The Coming Medical Ethics Crisis" over at Reason.com:
In 2010 the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act established an Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB). Beginning in 2014, the 15 presidential appointees on this board will determine what therapies, procedures, tests, and medications will be covered by Medicare, using advice provided by the FCCCER. Such determinations will then be used to design the coverage packages for the non-Medicare insurance offered through the government–run exchanges. The decisions of the IPAB are not subject to Congressional oversight or judicial review.
I have not corroborated some of the information from the article.  Read it all, and consider that the source is a doctor.  Then stay on the lookout for information that confirms (or contradicts) the details and don't say nobody warned us.


Update:  Altered the title and tags to reflect the fact that the fact check was done by PolitiFact's Florida franchise.

Sunday, March 06, 2011

Shooting magic blanks

Our favorite St. Petersburg Times commie columnist*, Robyn "Blumñata" Blumner is at it again, celebrating anniversary after anniversary of the perfect marriage between economic cluelessness and leftist ideology.

Perhaps that's redundant.

Anyhow, Blumñata's latest column blasts Republicans for supposedly presenting tort reform as a magic bullet for controlling the increase in health care costs before offering her own solution based on little more than a rhetorical "Abracadabra!"

On Republican magic bullets:
While everyone agrees that spiraling Medicaid costs are a problem that need addressing, Republican politicians would have you believe that tort reform is the magic bullet to cost containment, winning them plaudits and contributions from the medical community.
According to my recollection, Republicans advanced tort reform as a conspicuously missing piece of Democratic Party health care reform proposals.  Blumner apparently thought it unnecessary to provide any example of the type of advocacy with which she charges Republicans.

But at least she comes through with a stellar example when it comes to her own magical thinking:
While defensive medicine — where doctors order tests and procedures as a hedge against malpractice suits — undoubtedly adds unnecessary costs, it is not the main driver. That dishonor goes to one overarching factor: bad jobs — something Republicans don't want to talk about.
Blumner's claim is sheer lunacy, unless by "bad jobs" she literally means jobs that result in making it more likely that workers will require expensive medical care.  The only thing a bad job does is make health care, at whatever price it carries, less affordable.

This is an important distinction progressives like Blumner seem to handle with difficulty.  Suppose we had available a spinal replacement surgery, but it came a cost of $2 trillion per procedure.  In Blumner's world, spinal replacement surgery represents a terrible thing because it's just one more way that health care is unaffordable.  And such prices help necessitate universal coverage where "the rich" share the costs of expensive procedures.  That way, rich folks like Bill Gates can be forced to help underwrite spinal replacement surgery for dozens of people who can't even afford basic health insurance.

Of course, we don't have spinal replacement surgery at any cost--yet.  But the hypothetical procedure illustrates the primary driver of increased medical costs:  medical innovation.

If the only medical care we had was plaster casts, pain killers and 19th century surgical procedures then medical costs would be very low today.  It's not that hard to saw off a leg.  Medical costs increase rapidly because the technology to accomplish more medical treatment is increasing rapidly.  And even when a new advance is relatively inexpensive, such as treatment for erectile dysfunction, overall medical costs increase because people expect such treatments to make up part of their medical care.  That's why even Viagra was covered for a time under Medicare.

The cost (price) of treating erectile dysfunction went down.  The amount of money spent (cost) of treating erectile dysfunction went up.  It's a classic supply-and-demand curve.

And then there's the cost of health insurance as contrasted to the price of health care.  As above, if health insurance covered plaster casts, pain killers and 19th century surgical procedures then health insurance would be extremely affordable--no doubt a small fraction of what it costs today given coverage of everything from cancer treatment to substance abuse treatment.  But government regulators tell insurance companies what they have to cover.  And because so many expensive health procedures exist, the cost of covering the risk of providing those procedures grows right along with it.  The consumer foots the bill where the state mandates increases in the cost of shared risk.

If Blumner has any clue about any of this then her expertise in hiding it for the purpose of her columns cannot be questioned.


* I don't know that Blumner's a communist.  People in the comments section at the Times like to call her that, and I like alliteration ("commie columnist").  She likes organized labor and big government.  She calls herself an atheist.  So if she's not a communist then at least she has a thing or two in common. The description is not intended to identify her as a communist, however.  It is intended as alliterative hyperbole.



Hat tip to JD for pointing out the mess I had made of the third paragraph.  A redundancy has been removed and the phrasing changed slightly to meet my exceedingly high standards of something-or-other.

Thursday, January 07, 2010

E. J. Dionne tries to reconcile numbers in health care bill

Bear in mind that the CBO figures showing a net deficit reduction for our most recent version of the health care bill include the caveat that the Medicare savings may not materialize.  Dionne was answering a question posed to him on the Hugh Hewitt Show, and I rely on Hewitt's transcript:
"Well, some of it, what they’re talking about is moving away from fee for service medicine. And they’re talking about a lot of different ways of charging people for medicine that encourage activities by doctors that deliver care more efficiently. The truth is we are shifting money that’s paid into the health care system one way, and paying it back into the health care system another way. And so I am persuaded that you are not going to see seniors, once this thing actually takes effect in 2014, or 2013, if they back it up a little bit, I don’t think you are going to see seniors wildly unhappy. And I think you’re going to see a lot of seniors very happy as they close the donut hole on the prescription drug benefit. So again, I think some of the polling among seniors against the bill reflects the fact that this generation of seniors is very Republican compared to the earlier, the earlier New Deal generation of seniors. So I think that when you’re talking politically, a lot of seniors are going to say the bill is bad, and they’re going to vote Republican. But guess what? Seniors voted for John McCain over Barack Obama. I think that politically, what’s going to be interesting is the behavior probably 10-15% of seniors who are persuadable by your side of this or by the other side of this."
One comment from Dionne reminds me of a criticism I read some days ago.  That critic charged the bill with budgetary sleight of hand for counting Medicare savings as part of the overall savings, if I remember correctly, in spite of the fact that the money is spent regardless.  Dionne seems to play up that bug as a feature.  But how can seniors have any assurance that the saved monies will go toward care for the Medicare population?  I detect no such assurance.

The later satisfaction Dionne expects comes, I believe, from the satisfaction folks usually have with a service they do not use, combined with the satisfaction of at least a few who actually use the service.

Hewitt has a good number of transcripts dealing with the health care issue, many featuring the words of those who favor the legislation.

Thursday, December 24, 2009

Reason.com: "Obama's Latest Health Care Lie"

I wonder if PolitiFact will report on this one?
That would be in remarks the president made yesterday:
The Congressional Budget Office now reports that this bill will reduce our deficit by $132 billion over the first decade, and by as much as $1.3 trillion in the decade after that.  So I just want to be clear, for all those who are continually carping about how this is somehow a big spending government bill, this cuts our deficit by $132 billion the first 10 years, and by over a trillion in the second.  That argument that opponents are making against this bill does not hold water.
There are actually multiple lies and deceptions in this paragraph, beginning with the verb "reports" to describe what the Congressional Budget Office does.
Read the whole of it.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

NHS: No, we will not approve use of an effective liver cancer drug

More on the compassion of the single-payer system of health insurance:
A drug that can prolong the lives of patients with advanced liver cancer has been rejected for use in the NHS in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
Quality care for all. Wait a minute! You there! Not you.

The market does it better, in concert with personal human caring.

Thou shalt have abortion rights

Robyn Blumner calls herself an atheist. But I think she's religious.

Her religion is reproductive self-determination. But not that heretic branch that claims that women have the right to have as many babies as they wish. She's of the sect that holds the right to an abortion as sacrosanct.

Which brings us to her editorial column in last week's St. Petersburg Times:
In the vote on health care reform offered by the House Democratic leadership, women were given the status of potted plants. It didn't seem to matter that women generally vote Democratic at substantially higher rates than men, their reproductive health care was sacrificed on the altar (and it was an altar) of getting the thing passed.
No wonder she's mad. The altar of a competing religion was getting in the way. Better no health care bill than to see her religion slighted?

On with the sermon:
Rep. Bart Stupak, a Democrat from Michigan and a purported member of the secretive fundamentalist Christian group known as The Family, threatened House Speaker Nancy Pelosi like a spoiled child possessing the playground's only basketball. He promised to let health reform fail, with about 40 members in tow, unless the bill included his amendment that barred abortion coverage from any public option or private health insurance plan purchased with federal subsidies.
I'm sure there are times when Blumner recognizes rights of conscience. But not where her religion is concerned. If the courts recognize the constitutional right of a mother to kill a fetus, then taxpayers need to pay for it whether or not they find it highly objectionable.

From what I can tell, the bit about "The Family" is an unsubstantiated rumor. Stupak lists his religion as Roman Catholic and maintains a membership at a Roman Catholic church in his home state. Classy of Blumner to mention the rumor.

Pelosi didn't have a choice. Even with Stupak's amendment, health care reform squeaked by on a vote of 220 to 215.

The stubborn position of Stupak and his lobbying partner, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, is made even more extreme by the fact that a compromise had been reached to protect the status quo's strict limits on federal funding of abortion. The House bill contained a provision directing health insurers in the new exchanges to segregate federal subsidies from private premiums and use only the private funds to pay for abortion coverage. No public money would be used for abortions except in cases of rape, incest or to save the life of the mother.

What a laughable compromise. Private religious schools should try that one sometime. Let them receive federal money, but keep it segregated from the religious activities of the school.

I'd give Blumner ... 2.5 seconds to blow her top if that arrangement became reality.

Funny how Blumner noticed Stupak's alliance with the USCCB but without letting on that he is a Roman Catholic.

But Stupak and his fellow conservative Democrats wanted more. They wanted to use health reform as an antiabortion tool. Stupak's amendment means insurers in the exchanges are unlikely to offer plans including abortion coverage since most customers will be federally subsidized.

It makes you wonder whom Stupak's team is playing for?

I suppose it is too much to assume that Stupak's well-known Catholicism and the associated probability that he would adopt a pro-life stance was known to Michigan voters. Let's go with the rumor that he is part of the secretive cult known as "The Family."
Passing health reform is the Democrats' top domestic policy priority. In addition to helping save nearly 45,000 people who die every year from a lack of health insurance, Democratic hopes in midterm elections may ride on its successful passage.
Funny stuff! Why is health care reform the Democrats' top domestic policy priority when unemployment is over 10 percent? And why push it when the price tag is so high while the federal deficit is blowing up like a passenger-side airbag after a high-speed collision? Especially when the American people are not behind it? Whether Blumner likes it or not, a majority of Americans oppose providing abortion services under the health care reform bill:
At least on the level of rhetoric, all the politicians and outside groups that have weighed in on health reform seem to agree: taxpayers shouldn't pay to fund abortion. "No federal dollars will be used to fund abortions," said Barack Obama in his speech to Congress on Sept. 8. His Democratic colleagues say they agree with the same principle, as do GOP leaders. That stance mirrors public opinion as well. A 2008 Zogby poll found that 69% of Americans oppose "taxpayer funding of abortion."
It makes no sense except as a long-term strategy to make Americans more dependent on government and thus more likely to vote for the Democrats who dependably vote for more spending on entitlements. Not counting Medicare under the health care reform bill, of course.

Short term, the Democrats will not do well politically to pass health care reform legislation--except with the hard left base. Blumner must be smoking something to think otherwise.

So what else is she thinking these days?
But Stupak and his crew were prepared to trade their own party's electoral prospects and all those lives for a rule that tells low- and middle-income women that they are on their own to pay for a needed abortion. Even in cases where the fetus is deformed and won't survive outside the womb.
As pointed out above, the federal health care reform legislation is unpopular as it is, and it would be even more unpopular if abortion coverage was included. With a reality base like that, Blumner should get Lucy in the Sky to give her enough diamonds to retire from the editing biz.

I'm kind of wondering about this "needed abortion" thing. The reform legislation includes an exception where the life of the mother is at risk. What are the other times an abortion is "needed"? It seems to me that a "needed, elective abortion" is oxymoron territory.
The Catholic bishops also made that calculation. To them, standing in the way of health coverage for an additional 36 million people — which they did aggressively — was worth it. Because now, maybe, some working woman who can't possibly afford another child since she can't even pay for an abortion, will be forced to have an unwanted baby. That was their compassionate, charitable reckoning.
The compassionate thing, evidently, would be to kill the fetus. Beezlenut! Beezlenut! Rah! Rah! Rah! It's not like people adopt babies or anything. And it's not like we'll need workers to pay for the health care of retiring baby boomers.
Whatever the numbers, the reason Stupak and the bishops were so keen to get their regressive amendment through was to make it harder for women to exercise their right to choose.
Probably not. The amendment probably would not make it any harder for a woman to have an abortion than it is at present. If Blumner meant to say that Catholics wanted to keep abortion from becoming an easier choice, that may be accurate. But the rights of conscience should not be discounted without mention.

Blumner ends with a howler:
Every lawmaker with a shred of decency knows that health reform is essential for our nation's future. But reform can't take abortion access with it. Women have to count for something.
The implicit argument: Unless women receive federal funding for elective abortion, women count for nothing.

Is that stupid or what?

As a bonus, we get the implication that a health care reform bill that will either increase the deficit (while being advertised as a deficit cure) or result in much higher taxation--during a recession, no less--is essential to the nation's future.

Dude.

Universal health care all about compassion?

I often see the argument that the universal, single-payer plan is all about compassion. So it was almost refreshing to see an editorial from the St. Petersburg Times that stepped far away from that position.

The editorial, titled "Science, not emotion," discussed the new mammogram schedule recommended by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. The facts of the matter illustrate how preventive care is not always cost effective care. Women under 50 years of age were getting rather little bang for their mammogram bucks.

The transition to the bitter pill at the end was a bit rough:

The United States spends roughly 16 percent of its gross domestic product on health care — far more than many other developed countries. Britain long ago adopted a less stringent standard: Begin mammograms at 50 and have them every three years. The task force didn't go that far, and its recommendations deserve thorough vetting by the broader medical community. And women in their 40s should always have the option to finance mammograms either out of pocket or through optional insurance coverage.

But a basic tenet of our health care system must include a willingness to base medical standards on science, not emotion. That is the only chance the country has for making health care more available and affordable for all.

Note: "(W)omen in their 40s should always have the option to finance mammograms either out of pocket or through optional insurance coverage."

Um--what about the "right" to health care?

No?

The editors don't quite get it. A government-controlled system is highly likely to decrease availability of mammograms. Take Canada, for example:

In early 2008, women in southeast New Brunswick who wanted a routine mammogram had to wait more than a year to get an appointment. That has changed since the first of two digital mammogram units have been added to the Moncton Hospital.

Rachelle Gaudet, the manager of diagnostic imaging services for Regional Health Authority B, said women now have to wait about 32 weeks to get a routine screening.

Granted, waiting for a year or so provides women more time to save money to pay for the mammogram. But they'll pay more because of scarcity, and they'll have to wait.

The last paragraph from the editorial serves as the paper's admission that single-payer health care is not thoroughly compassionate. If it was, we could base the decisions on emotion instead of science. Or at least science plus economics. We have the science to provide early mammograms. It is economics that ultimately discourages providing them early and often.

Now I'll start hoping that the Times will admit that the single-payer system would discourage medical innovation.


Tuesday, November 03, 2009

Video: Don't copy European heathcare



I do not recall ever seeing a parallel message from the news pages of a United States newspaper.

Instead, we get stories like this one in the St. Petersburg Times: "Oh, Canada, where health care for all 33 million is free."

No, that's the real title of the story. Seriously.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Are there no islands in the Fever Swamp?

I dropped "Comments From Left Field" from the Sith blogroll for serial incompetence.

Today, I stopped off at "The Daily Kos" for port side edification.

As luck would have it, the very first story I looked at proposed a "simple" version of the single-payer health insurance plan that consisted of eliminating the social security tax and replacing it with a 10 percent payroll tax apparently dedicated to funding medical care.

Some of us might wonder how we fund Social Security after making that move. That is where the silver lining comes in.

Yes, a blogger published this plan at The Daily Kos. But problems were quickly pointed out in the comments section, and the blogger almost as quickly understood the problems:
Stupid on my part. The numbers I've had in my head are from our total MediCare and Medicaid expenditures, which were $750 billion in 2007, and have little do do with the $850 billion collected from FICA etc.

Clearly I need to spend more thought on this, though I believe that this is the way to go for paying the bills, though to maintain a robust Senior Retirement plan the rate will obviously have to be higher, more like 13-14% shared.

Well, almost understood the problems. Social Security is on the fast track to insolvency with a weakened economy and burgeoning expenses brought on by boomer retirement. Ditto for Medicare, since the bulk of medical expenses occur during the twilight years. Seven percent for FICA probably won't cut it without an associated cut in benefits (how do we define "robust"?).

But let's assume that FICA can remain the same. The idea was to fund medical care through payroll taxes.

It turns out that the proposal was entirely based on dubious reasoning. The writer took total health care costs for 2007 and tried to devise a tax plan for today that would raise that amount of money.

The problem is obvious: Health care spending is increasing rapidly.

The source used by the Kos kid
to provide a $2.4 trillion baseline for 2007 went on to project an increase to $3.1 trillion by 2012.

I suppose that leaves the option of cranking the payroll tax up a percentage point or so every year.

Some liberals seem to have faith that there will always be enough "rich" people to tap for the added costs, but these numbers reflect huge percentages of the GDP. As a percentage of rich person income and/or assets the numbers are unsustainable.

Now take a guess why conservative critics predict that single-payer health care will result in lower quality rationed health care.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

The truth about the truth about health care (Updated)

Robyn "Blumñata" Blumner is back at it again this week with another nonsensical foray into editorial journalism.

Not that Blumñata has been on vacation since the last time I dissected one of her granfalloonian offerings. She finally wrote something focused enough to warrant a relatively focused reply. Much of her work this year consists of laundry list attacks on either the Bush administration or conservatives in general.

This week she puts her abysmal knowledge of economics on display as she writes in favor of single-payer health care.
Universal health care is a benefit that a large majority of Americans say they want. It would grant Americans some semblance of the kind of peace-of-mind that Canadians and Western Europeans enjoy. We wouldn't have to worry that a job loss would also put our family's health coverage at risk. And on and on.
A large majority of Americans want universal health care? A pity that Blumner failed to name her source. Here is one, from 2003, that calls her claim into question.
In an extensive ABCNEWS/Washington Post poll, Americans by a 2-1 margin, 62-32 percent, prefer a universal health insurance program over the current employer-based system. That support, however, is conditional: It falls to fewer than four in 10 if it means a limited choice of doctors, or waiting lists for non-emergency treatments.
(ABCNews.com)
Focusing simply on the first sentence, one would think that universal health care appeals greatly to Americans. But the four in 10 mentioned subsequently is not a majority, and doctor shortages and waiting lists are quite likely with universal health care.

At least we can say that Americans like the idea of pie-in-the-sky health care. Who could be against that minus the problems?

But even Blumñata admits there are problems:
But expanding health coverage to everyone is going to mean higher taxes in some form as well as other sacrifices, such as enforceable cost controls on the medical establishment and some practical limits on patient medical services. Expensive medical procedures that don't demonstrably work or have about the same outcomes as cheaper methods are going to have to be eliminated from coverage. Drugs too will have to prove their efficacy. Welcome to the age of generics.
Higher taxes is a huge drawback to universal health coverage. This represents a core inconsistency with both President Obama's domestic policy and Blumñata's thinking.

Think about it. Mr. Obama is selling health care reform as an economic salve. But that is ridiculous. Sure, decreased spending on health care decreases the percentage of GDP spent on health care--but it also decreases the GDP, particularly where the expenses return workers to their jobs faster.

***
Interruption via update: To make myself clear, decreased spending on health care decreases the GDP generally, while the rapid return of workers to their jobs shrinks the percentage of GDP spent on health care as a percentage of GDP generally.

I apologize for the poor job I did expressing that idea.

***

But back to her list of admitted problems.
  • cost controls
  • limits on patient medical services
To be sure, Blumñata offers only one example in support of these euphemistic-sounding drawbacks. Expensive treatments that do not work well would be eliminated as options, she says, and where two treatments offer about the same benefit the more expensive of the two would be sidelined.

It is neither that simple nor that benign.

Cost controls will very probably include restrictions on your choice of doctors as well as limitations on seeing a specialist. They will probably include (perhaps only when the money starts to run out) assessments on the quality of life a patient expects following treatment. They will include rationing of services, which will grow gradually more pronounced as the wealth of medical resources produced by our past systems turns obsolete. As for Blumner's example of reduced availability of medications, doctors often have clinical reasons for choosing a more expensive medication. Patients do not always respond the same way to medicine, and some medicines do not work well in conjunction with other therapies.

The benign-sounding push toward efficiency is, by analogy, an initiative that removes tools from the doctor's toolbox, and, instead of your doctor, the government will decide which tools belong in there.
Knowing there will be costs and how much Americans hate the thought that lunch may not be free, opponents to health care reform have already launched a "Harry and Louise" style scare campaign. A group called Conservatives for Patients' Rights expects to spend up to $20 million on television ads that feature patients and doctors in Canada and Britain complaining about long waits for surgery or how they couldn't get needed medications under their national health care.
Sometimes the truth hurts, which is probably why single-payer proponents like Blumñata want to poo-poo the real problems with the idea by labeling it as a "scare campaign." The poll above shows how support for universal health care shrinks based on the existence of its traditional drawbacks. Conservatives who want to publicize those drawbacks are simply trying to scare people. Or something:
It is designed to make you want to desperately cling to the status quo.
I doubt it, for the admitted problems with the current system stem largely from government involvement, including the ramifications for malpractice within the framework of the U.S. legal system. Other problems stem from attaching health care to employment--a problem presidential candidate John McCain had hoped to address with his health care reform plan--and the third party payment system as represented by private insurance, Medicare and Medicaid.

As for the supposed desperation:
PRINCETON, NJ -- Despite ever-increasing healthcare costs and widespread dissatisfaction with the U.S. healthcare system, a majority of Americans remain satisfied with what they pay for their own healthcare, the quality of the healthcare they receive, and their healthcare coverage.
(gallup.com)
What, Blumñata never told you that? Most of you are supposed to be desperate! Now get with the socialist pogrom! Er, I mean program.
Of course, President Barack Obama isn't suggesting that we adopt a single-payer system like these other countries have — which is too bad in my view.
Obama has said that he prefers the single-payer plan. But he also clearly realizes that an immediate switch to a single-payer plan is a high political risk. His plan immerses the medical system frog in a pot of tepid water and starts heating it gradually from the bottom. Before you know it, you're cooked.
Reality: Obama Has Consistently Said That If We Were Starting From Scratch, He Would Support A Single Payer System, But Now We Need To Build On The System We Have
(barackobama.com)
No doubt that prospect makes Blumñata impatient.
People in the United States seem to like our own single-payer government-run program: Medicare.
Sure they do. So long as they aren't thinking about the incredible waste in the Medicare system along with the fact that it already consumes over 16 percent of federal spending (Social Security included). National defense takes up about 19 percent.

clipped from www.factcheck.org

blog it

The Medicare budget just keeps expanding, and the baby boomers will push its expenses to even more amazing heights. Sorry if that sounds scary, but it is reality. There is one way to avoid the problem: Cut and/or ration services. The only part of his plan for Medicare that Obama will currently admit, so far as I'm aware, is the part that expands the government's share of medical costs and raises taxes to pay for it. Is that fiscal responsibility? Seriously?

Back to Blumñata:
And as to the poor Canadians who can't get decent medical care? A 2008 Harris poll of how the citizens of 10 developed countries feel about their health care system found the United States dead last, with fully a third of Americans saying our system needs to be completely rebuilt. Meanwhile, Canada's system was third-highest in popularity.
Hmm. Blumñata left out the poll's conclusion to the effect that all the nations surveyed had majorities calling for health care reform.
Regardless of what system a country has it falls far short of satisfying public expectations. Most systems always seem to be in a crisis or near crisis.
(harrisinteractive.com)
It is true that the U.S. system ranks last among the nations surveyed in terms of native popularity. But there could be innumerable reasons for that other than quality of care, including the existence of a pervasive negative message from the national press.

Blumñata again:
But the folks coordinating the ads don't let the facts stand in their way.
They'll face a stiff challenge in ignoring more facts than our own Blumñata. Rather than start in on how those folks play with the facts, she engages in four paragraph's worth of personal attacks against Rick Scott of Conservatives for Patients' Rights. Supposedly it is relevant that the hospital group Scott once headed, HCA, was found guilty of various wrongs even if Scott himself was charged with nothing and convicted of nothing.

Too cute.

After apparently exhausting her supply of facts misrepresented by Scott (without ever starting on it), Blumñata runs off to attack the strategy she says Republicans will use to oppose Obamacare:

Republicans in Congress are positioning themselves in this camp too. They're working from a 28-page attack plan by GOP strategist Frank Luntz, an expert on phrasing political positions for maximum advantage. The plan lays out ways to defeat Obama's health care reforms by painting Democrats as wanting "to put Washington politicians in charge of your health care."

The charge is absurd since Obama's intention is to leave current health insurers in place while offering a government plan as an alternative. But there may be real trouble in holding congressional support together when the new costs and sacrifices necessitated by a $120 billion universal health care plan start coming clear.

Somehow, Blumñata has worked in an editorial position with a newspaper for over 15 years without apparently realizing that Congress controls the expenditures of the government. Along with not realizing that government insurance automatically carries a competitive advantage over private insurance. Know of any private insurance companies that can levy general taxes in order to support their bottom line?

How long did it take for Florida's state-sponsored homeowner's insurance entity to its current status as Florida's #1 homeowner's insurance company?
The Florida Legislature created Citizens Property Insurance Corp. in 2002 when it merged two existing state-backed insurance pools, the Florida Residential Property and Casualty Joint Underwriting Association and the Florida Windstorm Underwriting Association. Commonly called Citizens, it is now Florida's largest home insurer. As of November 2007, Citizens insured more than 1.4 million homes, condos and businesses in Florida.
(SunSentinel.com)
FYI, the Florida Residential Property and Casualty Joint Underwriting Association was established way back in 1992. The Florida Windstorm Underwriting Association is comparatively ancient, kicking off in 1970 to cover properties in the Florida Keys. In any event, they demonstrate the tendency of government entities to grow. A big part of that growth stems, in this case, from the state insurers exemption from leverage rules applied to private insurers.

So, yes, the plan set forth by Obama does increase the government's role in health care and that role is likely to incrementally increase, leading to exactly the types of problems characteristic of single-payer programs--unless the political pressure brought by groups such as Scott's prevent it.

And for Blumñata it isn't just the supposed misrepresentations by Scott, it is the method they supposedly intend to employ.

She quotes a portion of the Frank Luntz "attack plan," but where is the rest of the so-called "attack plan"? I have been unable to find a copy of it online. If it is so bad, then why not publicize the whole thing? Why quote tiny portions from the 28 pages without any surrounding context?

Maybe that's the only way to keep Luntz from misleading people? Keep the people from accessing the information?

Bottom line, Obama's health care reform as part of an economic stimulus is a dangerous fantasy. And the resulting health care system will surely deliver a lower quality of care even if it satisfies people who believe they would have to pay for their own care otherwise. Speaking of free lunch.

Friday, October 10, 2008

Grading PolitiFact: Obama health plan fines small businesses?

This PolitiFact outfit simply astounds me.

People who should be serious journalists get into a fact-checking game--a good gig for journalists on the surface--and then proudly announce that they will boldly grade the truth of political claims with a needle graphic.

The resulting grades are about as dependable as figuring the truth via Ouija board.

The latest example: The McCain claim that Obama's health care plan will fine small businesses.

At the second presidential debate in Nashville, John McCain attacked Barack Obama's health care plan.

Obama's plan calls for "mandates and fines for small businesses," McCain said.

"If you're a small business person and you don't insure your employees, Senator Obama will fine you — will fine you. That's remarkable," McCain said.

That's the issue.
But we find that when you dig into the nitty gritty of Obama's plan, that's not the case.
And there's the judgment.

The judgment is based on two factors. First, PolitiFact fact-checker Angie Drobnic Holan notes that Obama's plan exempts small businesses of unspecified size. And that is a fair criticism, since McCain's statement could easily be taken to refer to all small businesses. So at best McCain's statement is partially true based on this factor.

The PolitiFact entry notes that Obama does not specify the size of a small business that would qualify for the exemption. And apparently that does not trouble Ms. Drobnic in the least when it comes to judging McCain.

It is possible to get an estimate out of the Obama camp, however. Why PolitiFact doesn't share this is beyond me, unless they don't want readers to know about it.
"The number would almost certainly be higher than ten employees," Furman added when asked if a recent non-partisan study by the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center was correct in assuming that Obama would exempt "small businesses" with fewer than 10 employees from the pay-or-play system.
(ABC News blog)
Eleven? Twelve? Thirteen? "Furman" is Jason Furman, Obama's director of economic policy.

If the number might be 10 or lower, then it could be that small businesses will have to pay into a pool if they do not provide insurance to their employees. And that brings us to the second factor that results in the goofy PolitiFact rating:
McCain calls this a "fine," but being required to contribute to a pool is not the same as paying a penalty for some wrongdoing.
Actually, being required to contribute to a pool can be the same as paying a penalty for some wrongdoing. Any distinction probably requires hair-splitting.
a sum of money imposed as a penalty for an offense or dereliction: a parking fine.
(Dictionary.com)

a sum of money paid to settle a matter; esp., a sum required to be paid as punishment or penalty for an offense.
(Webster's New World College Dictionary, Fourth Edition)
Under Obama's plan, isn't Obama implicitly declaring businesses that do not provide insurance "derelict"? Is the government not requiring the business to pay in order to "settle a matter" like providing insurance to an employee?

Angie Drobnic Holan's analysis requires a specialized understanding of the term "fine" and as such amounts to a fallacy of equivocation. But combining the fallacy with the unspecified small business exception, PolitiFact gives us the following:
So even by a generous definition, Obama does not fine "small businesses." Indeed, they are not even subject to the mandate. We rate McCain's claim False.
It simply doesn't follow that a "generous definition" gets Obama off the hook for fining small businesses. On the contrary, a "generous definition" of "fine" puts Obama squarely on the hook. Likewise a "generous definition" of "small business" puts Obama squarely on the hook.

Without at least a ballpark definition of "small business" from the Obama campaign it is irresponsible to rate McCain false for finding small businesses vulnerable to a fee imposed for not insuring workers. The narrow and unjustified redefinition of "fine," to McCain's disadvantage, is even more egregious.

PolitiFact rates an "F" on this one.


***

Just a small addendum.

Angie Drobnic Holan's distinction between a "fine" and a requirement that businesses pay into a pool if they fail to provide insurance reminds me of past experience. I rented from a landlord who imposed a "non-refundable deposit."

Can anybody tell me the difference between a "non-refundable deposit" and a fee?

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Blumner expands her realm of credibility, albeit in an unhealthy way

I'll have to grant Robyn Blumner, that pinata of the St. Petersburg Times, an area of expertise.

After all the cherry-picking she did for this week's editorial, I'll have to take her very seriously the next time she writes about the plight of agricultural workers.

The topic this week, along with the customary swipe at Bush and/or Republicans, is health care.
Rudy Giuliani has been called "Bush with brains" by those who fear that the former New York City mayor shares a penchant for unbridled executive power. But the Republican presidential primary front-runner seems to have a screw loose when it comes to campaigning. His attack on Hillary Clinton's health care proposal with the bugaboo of European-style "socialized" medicine is not only full of factual holes but it will surely bite him in the butt if he makes it to the general election.
(St. Petersburg Times)
Cherry-pick No. 1: "(F)ull of factual holes" but Blumner will only mention one, regarding Giulianni's imprecise use of cancer statistics earlier in the campaign.

Cherry-pick No. 2:
Polls regularly show that Americans are disgusted with the current state of affairs. In a 2007 CBS News/New York Times poll, nine in 10 respondents said that the U.S. health care system needs fundamental changes and two-thirds said it was up to the federal government to guarantee that all Americans have health care coverage.
In the paragraph just preceding the one above, Blumner assures the reader that the voters "won't be fooled again" regarding Sen. Clinton's health care magic. Not many will bother looking up the poll Blumner cited, unfortunately.

The numbers she cites are accurate, albeit the wisdom of the mob isn't necessarily the best guide to public policy (I'll point Blumner to the approval for the Iraq War in 2003 if she looks askance). On the other hand, she's not telling the whole story.

Won't be fooled into thinking Hillarycare isn't the greatest thing since Social Security (we'll leave aside the fact that the younger generation correctly doubts that it will benefit from Social Security)?
CONFIDENCE IN HANDLING HEALTH CARE
(Among registered voters)
Clinton Edwards Obama
Confident 36% 22% 25%
Uneasy 51 50 44
Don’t Know 13 28 31
(CBSnews poll, page 2)
With only 51% of registered voters polled "uneasy" about Sen. Clinton's health care initiative, how could people possibly be fooled this time? Perhaps Blumner hopes that by hiding part of the truth she can bring that embarrassing number down a bit.

Blumner's key statistic, the high public approval for a federal guarantee of health insurance, had a caveat in the original poll. Not the sort of thing a Blumner would wish to share with the public.
But only about half as many Americans – less than one in three - think the government can do a better job than private insurance companies at actually providing medical coverage. Many are not sure how government would fare in this role.
WOULD GOVERNMENT DO BETTER OR WORSE AT PROVIDING COVERAGE THAN PRIVATE COMPANIES?
Government better 30% Government worse 44 Don't know 23
(CBSnews poll, page 4)
A subsequent comment by Blumner nearly resulted in my eyes rolling violently enough to fly out of their orbits.
If the next president does nothing else but add this country to the pantheon of advanced nations that provide universal coverage, it will be a successful tenure -one that will be remembered fondly by generations to come, like that of FDR for Social Security and LBJ for Medicare.
The "advanced nations" that provide universal coverage are putting their citizens on waiting lists and admitting that the system is allowing people to die as a result.
So it is acutely awkward for his successor, Gordon Brown, that, 10 years on, his government is scrambling to fend off accusations of crisis in the NHS following a damning report about hospital infections that critics say is symptomatic of a wider malaise in British healthcare.
(Christian Science Monitor)
When you look at consumer satisfaction in Canada, it's as low as consumer satisfaction in the United States, which is extraordinary, given how high it was in Canada ten years ago.
(PBS, commentary by Sharon Glied, PhD)

Germany proposes radical plans to tackle financial crisis in health care
(British Medical Journal)

In short, these "advanced" countries are creating huge problems for themselves with their national health care plans. The problem, economically is the third-party payor problem, and it also wreaks its havoc with the privatized fraction of the U.S. system (the dirty little secret of American health care is that government regulation is causing many of the problems already). But Blumner won't want her sheeple to know any of that.

Yes, Roosevelt and LBJ were fawned over by the three generations who received the benefit of their ponzi schemes. The later generations will have ample reason to curse them, assuming the government will permit dissent at that point.

Roosevelt saddled the nation with a pyramid scheme that was never designed to abide a trend toward a graying and retired population. LBJ made it even worse.

But back to Blumner, for she has yet to exhaust her stupidity. This next line sums up the thrust of the rest of her editorial.
But guaranteed health care will not only serve to relieve the anxieties of tens of millions of American families, it will also be a shot of adrenaline to our economy.
This claim of Blumner's, by rights, should be entirely laughable. Has nationalized health care stimulated the economies of those nations who follow that path? Made them noticeably more efficient? If it has, then Europe's relatively weak economies seem even more pathetic.

Blumner's focus on the link between employment and health insurance seems curious, given that President Bush proposed portable insurance back in 2006.
  • Leveling the playing field by making the same tax relief available to individuals and employers. Americans who purchase HSA-qualified insurance policies on their own should have the same tax advantages as people who obtain insurance through their employer.
  • Eliminating all taxes on out-of-pocket spending through HSAs. Americans with HSAs should be able to pay for all of their care tax-free.
  • Making health insurance portable. Americans should be able to own the insurance policy that goes along with their HSA, and keep it when they change or lose their jobs without worrying about paying higher premiums if they become sick.
  • Strengthening the buying power of America’s small businesses. Small businesses should have the same access to price efficiencies as large businesses when purchasing health insurance.
  • Passing medical liability reform. Limit costly and frivolous lawsuits that waste scarce resources, increase health care costs, and drive doctors out of business.
  • Improving adoption of health information technology. Electronic health records that reduce costs and improve the efficiency and effectiveness of medical treatment should be widely used.
  • Empowering consumers through information. All Americans should be able to obtain easy-to-understand information about the price and quality of the health care they receive from their medical provider and insurance carrier.
  • Providing affordable coverage for vulnerable Americans. Americans with low incomes and persistently high medical expenses should receive additional assistance.
  • Promoting prevention, wellness, and fitness. The President encourages all Americans to lead a healthy lifestyle to prevent disease and improve their overall quality of life.
(whitehouse.gov)
I guess Blumner missed it.



*****

Friday, July 20, 2007

The "Greatest Generation" is getting on my nerves a little bit

clipped from www.aarp.org
logo

blog it


Senior citizens are ordinarily delightful. They are often founts of wisdom, and some of the funniest folks I've known were upwards of 70 years old. But AARP is little more than a tool of the Democratic Party, in effect.

I ran across a banner similar to the one above over a valued conservative site, with "It's time for health care and financial security for all" right next to it.

On the face of it, this "Divided We Fail" is a call for nationalized health care--and that's probably a very bad idea.
I don't want to say it's a completely bad idea, because I want to at least leave open the possibility that a nationalized plan could be thoroughly rigged with market incentives.

Of course, I don't want to blast the initiative without learning about it first.
We believe all Americans should have access to affordable, quality health care.

We believe...
All Americans should have access to affordable health care, including prescription drugs, and these costs should not burden future generations.
We believe...
Wellness and prevention efforts, including changes in personal behavior such as diet and exercise, should be top national priorities.
We believe...
Americans should have choices when it comes to long-term care - allowing them to maintain their independence at home or in their communities with expanded and affordable financing options

Well, doesn't that sound nice! Let's add "We believe our soldiers should win all wars without any casualties on either side." It's approximately as realistic, though the devil is in the details of "affordable health care."
There's no use complaining about the sentiment--it's a good sentiment.

We believe all Americans should have peace of mind about their future long-term financial security.

We believe...
Our children and grandchildren should have an adequate quality of life when they retire. Social Security must be strengthened without burdening future generations.
We believe...
Workers should be provided with financial incentives to save, should have access to effective retirement plans, and should be able to keep working and contributing to society regardless of age.
We believe...
Americans of all ages should have access to tools to help manage their finances, and save for the future and better, easy to understand information to help them increase their financial literacy and manage their money wisely.

Years ago, a friend of mine had this spontaneous comedy routine about his "Uneducated, Unemployed Party." The platform of the party was to provide education to nobody, and unemployment benefits for everybody. Since nobody would have to work, education was superfluous. This manifesto reminds me a bit too closely of the economic irresponsibility of my friend's joke.

We stand as strong champions for the new American dream -- to build a 21st century America where these issues are paramount so that all people can have the opportunity for a prosperous future. We also believe that individuals, businesses, health care providers, non-profit organizations, and government must work together to find solutions - personally, privately and publicly. We represent tens of millions of Americans and we believe that all of us share a responsibility for making our society work and restoring peace of mind to all Americans.

This is our platform for positive change and our commitment to current and future generations.

Divided We Fail, but together we can do anything.

(AARP.org)

"We can make beans ... into peas!"
If we can do anything, then let's tax all foreigners living abroad--that's about our best chance for putting this plan into effect.

Until we've got inexpensive machines providing health care, this plan doesn't have a snowball's chance.

Why?

Well, think about it. As health care improves, people live longer. As people live longer, the chances increase that they will require multiple episodes of expensive medical care. Not counting retirement benefits, a repeat customer getting nationalized healthcare can, without much trouble, exceed in expense the whole of his contributions into the system. And that's just the Medicare end of the problem. Third-party payment increases the demand for services (supply and demand: decrease the price of the service and you increase the demand for the service). As the population shifts demographically grayer, the percentage of the GDP dedicated to healthcare increases inexorably, which leads to rationing of services.

So, instead of affordable health care for all, you get health care for those the government decides will need it the most, when the government can get around to it.

Does it sound heartless to suggest that the government shouldn't pay for the health services of retired folks? No doubt it does, but the neglected truth is that a free market economy creates the kind of wealth that can spread benefits around widely. A robust free-market economy can sustain high health expenses. Taking healthcare out of the free market economy hampers the economy and contributes t0 the onset of rationed care.

[edit to add]
Where the plan does appeal to private business and individuals to come up with solutions, it has more than a snowball's chance. Individuals are best suited to knowing whether to pay for their own (or a family member's) medical care or not.

Monday, April 02, 2007

Criswell predicts: Medicine: 1982


Before we get into Criswell's next past future prediction, I was watching the Jamie Kennedy Experiment the other night, and Kennedy dressed up so that he could sit inside one of those fortune-telling machines for one of his hidden camera gags.

The name Kennedy chose for his fortune-telling alter-ego?

Caswell.

More than a coincidence, I think.

Now, forward to the past:
I predict that by 1982, that a full medical education will require six months of study. The reason for the shortening of medical education is simple: Everything in medicine will be automated, and a course to qualify one as a medical doctor will require only knowledge of how to operate the proper computers and other equipment.
--The Amazing Criswell

Not a whole great deal of medicine is automated even now in 2007. Sure, orthopods sometimes use robots to prepare hips and knees for a prosthesis, but that's the exception and it hasn't shrunk medical training noticeably.
I think it's worth recalling some dialogue from the film "Ed Wood" at this point.

Edward D. Wood, Jr.: Say, Cris, how'd you know we'd be
living on Mars by ... ?

The Amazing Criswell: I guessed.

Edward D. Wood, Jr.: Really?

The Amazing Criswell: I made it up.



Criswell, in his prediction about medicine, went on to say
Doctors themselves will be looked upon as merely public servants of the government, who will license the doctor and set fees for him, exactly as they will for plumbers, carpenterss, and sewer workers.

If Hillary Clinton wins the presidency in 2008, maybe.