Showing posts with label Gitmo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gitmo. Show all posts

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Blumner on vacation

Robyn "Blumñata" Blumner is on vacation, but still posting columns. I presume that her mode of travel caused more carbon to enter the atmosphere and place the planet in greater peril.

She's still posting columns, but instead of blaming recent violent demonstrations by Muslims on the detention facility at Gitmo, she's writing about how people in Russia and Eastern Europe know English.

Go figure.
Reporting from Kabul, Afghanistan —
Shouts of "Death to America!" rang out in Afghanistan on Saturday as more than 10,000 demonstrators denounced now-suspended plans by an American pastor to burn the Koran.

The protest in the city of Pul-e-Alam, about 35 miles south of Kabul, the Afghan capital, was initially peaceful but boiled over into violence as some demonstrators set shops ablaze and tried to storm the provincial governor's compound.
(Los Angeles Times)
Gitmo is also used as a major recruitment tool and motivation for violent jihadists ("explosive anger"):
“One jihadist posted a picture on the Shumukh al-Islam forum of a beheaded Pastor Jones, with words on the picture reading: ‘Punishment for whoever dares to transgress against the Book of Allah,’” SITE reported (pdf).

One of the jihadists sites called for terrorist attacks, referred to Jones’s plan, which he has since canceled, as “another example of the West insulting Islam and receiving only words of condemnation rather than physical retaliation,” SITE reported.
(Washington Post Blog)
I'm sure when Blumner returns from vacation she will soon renew the call for President Obama to close Gitmo.

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Steven Crowder at GITMO

Watch the whole thing. Crowder makes some great points, and the visuals are worth the time.

Tuesday, June 09, 2009

Hitchens on ex-Guantanamo terrorists

I often encounter the claim that the experience of a detainee at Gitmo accounts for the actions of ex-Gitmo inmates who engage in terrorist acts. Certain liberals claim that U.S. actions radicalized the men.

I've never known those who make this claim to provide evidence for it, other than a combination of the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy (after this therefore because of this) and the commonsense suggestion that falsely imprisoned people might well be expected to resent those who imprisoned them. I accept the latter, but I have some difficulty making the leap from resentment to terrorist acts. After all, we have people in the U.S. who experience false imprisonment and the like, and they don't seem to go terrorist in any great percentage.

Christopher Hitchens, that liberal journalist with an outlook on foreign policy that pleases conservatives more often than not, offered his opinion over at Slate:
(I)f we think it probable or possible that a man would only mutate into such a monster after undergoing the Guantanamo experience, then I can suggest one reason why that might be. Nothing prepared me for the way in which the authorities at the camp have allowed the most extreme religious cultists among the inmates to be the organizers of the prisoners' daily routine. Suppose that you were a secular or unfanatical person caught in the net by mistake; you would still find yourself being compelled to pray five times a day (the guards are not permitted to interrupt), to have a Quran in your cell, and to eat food prepared to halal (or Sharia) standards. I suppose you could ask to abstain, but, in such a case, I wouldn't much fancy your chances.
Hitchens makes a good point. The accomodation of the detainees' religious beliefs almost makes it a little Swat valley in a little corner of Cuba.

Though it often may simply be the case that the released detainees were radical to begin with.

Anyone with a line on good evidence showing that ill treatment of detainees results in radicalization is encouraged to point the way in the comments.

Thursday, January 29, 2009

The launch of the Obama presidency (Updated)

I wrote earlier that President Obama enters office facing some conditions similar to those faced by Jimmy Carter. Carter's presidency was largely a failed presidency, marked by a failure to significantly implement his legislative proposals stemming from his inability to secure solid support from either party or a combination thereof.

Accordingly, I have noted that Obama will have to choose his first set of issues very carefully. No doubt he has attempted to do that, and it is time to begin assessing his success.

1) The economy

Obama moved center with his proposal for economic stimulus. That was a good move. Unfortunately for the president, the Democrats in Congress have been less inclined to move center and the resulting bill (from the House, anyway) is much more partisan in character than the one Obama recommended. If the Senate increases the tax cut percentage reasonably close to his original proposal then a bipartisan bill may yet emerge. Obama gets a boost from that. Alternatively, the budget fight will help polarize conditions in the capital. The resulting bill will represent only the Democrats, and its relative lack of stimulative effect may come back to bite the party of the left.

I detect one plus for the Democrats in this scenario in that I think the basic problem with the economy is essentially fixed. I think the home market is poised to stabilize and grow. The current action of the government, in my view, will serve primarily to soften the bumps caused by the bad side of the business cycle, that is ,decreased consumer spending in the latter half of 2008 with the resulting loss of jobs as businesses cut labor and inventory. So the Democrats might look OK even with a relatively bad bill over the short term, though not likely worth the indebtedness that goes with it.

2) Gitmo

Obama decided to bite the bullet and commit to closing Gitmo. The move is a sop to his base but a difficult one to pull off to the satisfaction of the electorate generally. In recognition of the difficulty, Obama fashioned his strategy by putting the resolution of the issue on a year-long timetable without any initial details.

As noted above, making this a key early issue carries substantial risk in terms of exercising his political power over time.

Conclusion

Obama's choice of dealing with the economy was sound, albeit a bit obvious. His proposal was politically sound even if his rhetoric didn't always match up. Both issues carry substantial risk for Obama's presidency, though it's way too early to forecast the outcome in either case.

Update:
Ed Morrissey at Hot Air highlighted a report that a military judge has blocked President Obama's attempt to postpone the military tribunals for Gitmo detainees.

This opens up a rather kinetic can o' worms.
The Obama administration can withdraw charges, but to do so while keeping Nashiri detained will be tantamount to holding him without charge — which is what Democrats disliked about Gitmo in the first place. They could release him outright, but since Nashiri is one of the masterminds of the attack on the USS Cole, which killed 17 American sailors, it would be political suicide to do so.
So it may have taken Obama almost two weeks to walk into a political vise. This is likely to hurt.



Jan 20, 2010:  Fixed a number of typos, especially that one where the root word "debt" ended up with a "p" in it.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

"The Gitmo Act of 2008"

clipped from www.govtrack.us

110th CONGRESS

2d Session

H. R. 6615

To provide for the transport of the enemy combatants detained in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba to Washington, DC, where the United States Supreme Court will be able to more effectively micromanage the detainees by holding them on the Supreme Court grounds, and for other purposes.

blog it


I doubt the bill has any chance of becoming law, but it's nice to see this point made by a representative with a sense of humor.

Check this out:

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

    This Act may be cited as the ‘Giving Inmate Terrorists More Opportunities (GITMO) Act of 2008’.

I tip my hat to Rep. Louie Gohmert of Texas' 1st Congressional district.

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

A little background on Abdullah Mehsud

In the post linking to the story on the grenade suicide of Abdullah Mehsud, I wondered about his past, and what accounted for his role in terrorist operations in Pakistan. Pakistan's The News published a bio story.
He surrendered along with several thousand Taliban fighters to the forces of Uzbek warlord, Abdul Rashid Dostum, in December 2001 in the northern Kunduz province following the US invasion of Afghanistan. Despite his promise to the Taliban commanders not to deliver them to the US, Dostum handed several of them to the American military authorities. Abdullah Mahsud too was turned over to the Americans, who subsequently transferred him to the specially-built US prison at the Guantanamo Bay in Cuba.

He was released in March 2004 after spending 25 months at Guantanamo Bay. Until then, he wasn[']t well-known even in his native South Waziristan. But the stint in an American jail and his artificial leg soon made him a household name in the area. His long hair and daredevil nature made him a colourful and interesting character. Stories were told as to how Abdullah Mahsud rides a camel or horse to visit his fighters in his mountainous abode. He started making speeches in mosques and madrassas preaching Jihad and exhorting the young people to fight against the US and its allies.
(The News)
I don't know the source of author Rahimullah Yusufzai's statement that Mehsud served with Taliban forces, or the account of his capture. If true, it suggests that Mehsud was properly designated as an unlawful enemy combatant if he wasn't fighting in a Taliban uniform. His release from Gitmo after 25 months played a part leading to the kidnapping of two Chinese engineers and the five deaths that occurred during a subsequent rescue attempt.

Gitmo grad gets his via grenade

How many innocents died because we released this guy?

Hopefully it was one of those deals where we transferred custody to his home country--so it's their fault. But I wouldn't bank on it.

On the other hand, certain liberals might argue that he would never have served the Taliban if we hadn't imprisoned him first ...
clipped from www.abcnews.go.com
Abdullah Mehsud
Abdullah Mehsud, a former Guantanamo Bay prisoner, talks to the media as his bodyguard stand guard near Chagmalai in South Waziristan along the Afghan border in this Oct 14, 2004 file photo. Mehsud, who led pro-Taliban militants in Pakistan after his release, died on Tuesday, July 24, 2007 when he blew himself up with a grenade to avoid arrest. Armed intelligence agents cornered Mehsud and three other men at the house of a leader of an Islamist political party in the southwestern town of Zhob, police officials said. (M. Sajjad/AP Photo)

Jul 24, 2007
 blog it